Archive for May 29, 2009

Reading the Writing on the Brick Wall

Wordle: Names

I had intended to move on today and discuss the plantations that we’ve come across in our long way around the brick wall of my great-grandfather, Richard William Gines.  But I want to share an issue that has hindered our search and is not all that uncommon.    The Wordle graphic above tells the story!

To put the issue into genealogical research terms, watch as we follow my presumed collateral ancestor Rebecca Gines through her lifetime via the census.   She was enumerated each decade in  Tensas Parish, Louisiana.

(click on any image to enlarge)

1870

beck-guines-1870

Ancestry.com transcription:

Beckey Guines

Heritage Quest Transcription:

Beckey Guines

1880

reb-guines-1880

Ancestry.com Transcription:

Rebecca Guions

Heritage Quest Transcription:

Rebecca Guions

1900

beck-gioms-1900-cropped

Ancestry.com Transcription:

Beckie Gions

1910

rebecca-sines-lines-1910

Ancestry.com Transcription:

Rebecca Sines

Alt.: Rebecca Lines

HeritageQuest  Online Transscription:

Rebecca Lines

1920

[No record found]

1930

reb-gines-1930-cropped

Ancestry.com Transcription:

Rebecca Gines

Then at her death in Madison Parish:

rebecca1

Louisiana State Archives Death Index

In addition to the examples above, I found Gines family members indexed as “Genes,” “Gaynes,” and even “Sims.”  So I have not one surname to check, but really about a dozen.

How can it be determined that two spelling are the same name and not just different names?  One clue is the length of time the different spellings persist.  A short time for a spelling differential may suggest a mere mistake in spelling or transcription.  A lengthy period may suggest that there are different names involved.   Then, of course, one should check other records.  So where “Oscar Gines” appears on the census living in Shreveport and “Oscar Gimes” has the same address on his World War I draft card, a reasonable inference may be drawn that they are the same person.

There are myriad permutations of most names when one considers spelling, misspelling, mistranscription, mispronunciation, accents, and the lack of standardized spelling until the 19th or 20th centuries.

One thing that I do is examine the census pages some distance before and after my targeted individual.  I find a lot of related people, sometimes with names spelled differently, by this method.

Thanks to Wordle.net!

Memorial Day 2009

memorial_women(click for larger image)

If you haven’t been to Arlington Cemetery in the last several years, you may not recognize the memorial shown above.  It is the “Women in Military Service for America” memorial and it stands near the gate of the cemetery.

The women’s memorial is intended to recall all women who gave their lives in military service.   But there’s one group of servicewomen who were nearly forgotten by the Government with respect to recognition.  That group is the Women’s Airforce Service Pilots (“WASPs”) of World War II.   These were the first women pilots employed by the United States  military.

The government first used women to fly military airplanes in 1942.  The Women’s Auxiliary Ferrying Squadron (WAFS) was formed in September of that year under the command of Nancy Love at New Castle Army Air Base, Delaware.  This unit ferried aircraft from factories to airfields, freeing the male pilots for combat duty.

In 1943, the Army activated the 319th Women’s Flying Training Detahcment at Ellington Army Air  Field,  near Houston, Texas.  The commander was renowned aviator Jacqueline Cochran.  Later, the two women’s flying units were combined under the name “Women’s Airforce Service Pilots.”   Cochran was given overall command, and training was moved to Avenger Field near Sweetwater, Texas.

The women pilots flew almost every military aircraft in the U.S. inventory.  In addition to ferrying duty, the WASPs towed targets for live-fire antiaircraft exercises, trained male pilots in some of the advanced aircraft, flew simulated bomb and strafing runs for training combat troops, and performed other flying duties when and where necessary to relieve male pilots.

On March 3, 1943, Margaret Sanford Oldenberg of Contra Costa County, California, became the first WASP to die in the line of duty when her plane crashed five miles from the airfield.  Overall, thirty-eight women were killed in the line of duty.

But the Government did not consider the WASPs to be service veterans.  They were therefore entitled to no medals, and no funeral honors.  That changed somewhat in 1977 when Congress passed a law permitting the Secretary of Dfense to recognize the WASPs as having performed military duty.  Despite this change in status, the Army, which operates Arlington National Cemetery, refused to allow WASP members to be buried there until 2002.

In 2002, former WASP Irene Kinne Englund died at age 84.  Her family attempted to have her buried at Arlington based on her WASP service.  They were told that she eligible, but onl;y because her husband was a World War II veteran, not because of her own service.   Her daughter, Judith Englund, took up the cause for her mother and all WASPs. Several months later, the Army changed its mind.

One June 15, 2002, WASP Irene Kinne Englund became the first of her sisters of the air to have a full military funeral at Arlington.

Cross-posted at The Peripatetic Graveyard Rabbit along with up-to-the minute graveyard and cemetery news!

When A Wild Goose Chase Isn’t A Wild Goose Chase

Some Lessons from Our Pursuit of Egans Gines

We had started out to get past the brick wall of my great-grandfather, Richard William Gines, who was born in Bossier Parish, Louisiana, in about 1860.  After years no success either on the ground (we visited Bossier Parish as well as Caddo Parish in 2004 to research this matter) or online, we decided to take the long way around by studying a presumed collateral relative.  That person was Egan Gines, whose 1948 death certificate we found in the Louisiana State Archives. We chose him because he was not previously known to us, whereas all the other known collaterals had led us back to the brick wall!

We drilled into a number of databases and records and learned a few things about Egans Gines.  For example, we learned that he was born in Tensas Parish, but probably not in 1872 as his death certificate states.  We learned that he was the son Julia Turner Gines of Tensas Parish.  We discovered that his siblings were Tillmon, Zeke, and Jeff Gines. We found him in no census records.  We found no marriage license for Egans and discovered no apparent children.  We did not learn his father’s name, although we fingered a suspect (who is presumed innocent until paternity is “proven” by the Genealogical Proof Standard).

This “collateral” investigation took up a fair amount of time, and we came up for air, it seemed that we were no closer to Richard William Gines than we had been before.   Or were we?

One of the most useful bits of information to come out of the Egans Gines investigation was that he was born in Tensas Parish.  Some years ago, I had come across a transcription of the 1899 tax rolls for Tensas Parish. The transcription listed, among others, four people with the surname Gines. Two of them, “Don” Gines and Becky Gines, were living on a plantation called Marydale.  Both were denoted as “colored.”  Two others, Elisha Gines and Caroline Gines, resided at a place described as “Evergreen Plantation.”  They also were “colored.”

Those years ago, I couldn’t quite connect these folks with the other Gines families I was researching.  For one thing, I had a difficult time finding them in the census records.  Now, however, thanks to Egans, I can draw some things together.

In the search for Egans, I found in the 1870 census some other Gines families.  For example, in Tensas Parish’sSubdivision 105, there reside Milford “Guines,” 21 years old, Beckey “Guines,” 25, and Jane “Guines,” age 6.

1870 U.S. Federal Census; Subdivision 105, Tensas, Louisiana; Roll M593_532; Page 332; Image 664.

Following this family through the years, we find them in 1880 enumerated in Tensas Parish’s 4th Ward thusly:

Guions, Milford    B    M    27    Laborer                       Miss    Miss    Miss
Guions, Rebecca    B    F    30    Keeps House                  La    La    La
Guions, Ellen    B    F     6                                                        La    Miss    La
Guions, Mary    B    F     5                                                       La    Miss    La
Guions, Charles    B    M     9                                                 La     Miss    La
Guions, Dorsey    B    M     2                                                 La    Miss    La

Note the change in spelling of the surname.

1880 U.S. Federal Census; 4th Ward, Tensas, Louisiana; Roll: T9_472; Page: 164.1000; Enumeration District: 81; Image: 0330.

[Interestingly enough, it appears that Jane "Guines", who was counted at Milford and Beckey's home as a 6 year old in 1870, is in 1880 at age 15, living in the nearby home of Elijah and Caroline  "Guions" as their daughter-in-law.  She is apparently married to their son, Benjamin.]

And then twenty years later in 1900, in Tensas Parish,

1900-gions-tensas

(click to enlarge image)

1900 U.S. Federal Census; Police Jury Ward 3, Tensas, Louisiana; Roll T623_583 Page 10A; Enumeration District 110.

[Note yet another change in spelling].

There in Line 1, Dwelling #211, is Milford and Beckey’s son Charles, now grown with a wife and two daughters. (He married Luellen Roach of Tensas Parish). Scroll down a bit, and we find Milford and “Beckie” in dwelling #217 with sons Dorsey, 22, and Austin, 17 (he’s been born since the 1880 census, obviously).  And what of daughters Mary and Ellen, who would be in their mid-twenties now?  Ellen married one John David Jones in October of 1893 (she was 19 years old). In 1900, the Joneses still live in Ward 4 with one of their two children, Alic, who is six months old.

and Mary

Next, look at the next household, #218.  There’s Jane listed as a widow, and residing with her son Milford (named after his maternal grandfather), daughter Caroline (named for her paternal grandmother), and Nancie.  Three other children are listed with Jane: Alford Gines, Elnora Hill, and Isic Hill.  All three have been born since 1890. [What makes this interesting is that there exists a record that shows a Jane Gines marrying one Dave Banks in 1892 in Tensas Parish. So what happened to him and who are these children?  But that's another story!]

Finally, in 1910, Milford and Rebecca live with a grandson, whom we’re unable at this point to identify further.  And the spelling of their name has “stabilized.”

1910-milford-1

1910-milford-2

Nearby are son Charles and his family, whose name spelling is also “modernized.”

1910-census-header-tensas

1910-chas-tensas-1

Also close by is a Harry Gines with wife Jacklin and children Sara, Daniel, and Ella.  We’re not sure to whom this family is related.

1910-henry-tensas_edited

1910-henry-tensas

Milford Gines (the elder) died in 1930 at the age of 81.  Becky Gines then apparently moved to live with her son, Milford (the younger) in neighboring Madison Parish.  She died there in 1931 and her age was given as 90.

la-death-records-header

rebecca2

milford

rebecca1

Louisiana State Archives Death Records Database

(click on image to enlarge)

So why isn’t this a wild goose chase?  We still don’t know a lot more about the way around Richard William Gines, do we?

Well, sometimes brick walls come down a brick at a time.  Consider what we now know:

  • Significant numbers of people named Gines lived in Tensas Parish.
  • Gines-surnamed people apparently lived on two plantations, Evergreen Place and Marydale in Tensas Parish.
  • The surname Gines has a number of variant spellings and is also mis-transcribed in creative ways.

These are important steps forward and advance our flanking movement around the brick wall. So let’s keep going–you won’t believe what’s just ahead!

Next: The Plantations

Then: Bring out the Jackhammers! Time for this wall to fall!

The Mysteries of the Two Fiddles

im000313

The photograph on this page was taken on May 10, 2009, which    happened to be both Mother’s Day and the birthday of Edna Micheau Penny, who’s shown here.  She’s examining a violin which belonged to her father, Joseph Perry Micheau (1888-1975) of Prairie du Rocher, Illinois.  It had been many years since she had seen the violin.  Apparently, there is another violin like it at Creole House in Prairie du Rocher.

Where did these instruments come from?  Who taught their owners to play?  When and where did they play?

These are some of the mysteries of the two fiddles.

The Round-About Way Around Collaterals to Your Brick Wall

Sometimes when you run up against a brick wall, you may have to go a long way in a parallel or perpendicular path to get around the brick wall.  True in physics, true in life, true in genealogy.

In illustration of that point, we’ve been trying for a long time to get past the brick wall represented by my great-grandfather, Richard William Gines, who was born in Bossier Parish, Louisiana in about 1860.  He lived most of his life in Shreveport, Caddo Parish, and presumably died there between 1900 and 1910.

We’ve been unable to move linearly beyond Grandpa Dick.  But in the course of attempting to do so, we come across a lot of other folks in Louisiana named Gines. Perhaps pursuing one of these collaterals will lead us around the brick wall.  So we’ve been studying the matter of one Egans Gines who lived in Shreveport for some period of time before dying there in 1948.

We’ve “learned” (that is, we’ve seen record evidence from which we might reasonably infer) that Egans Gines was a child of Julia Turner Gines of Tensas Parish, Louisiana.  This information comes from his death certificate and analysis of census records. The problem is, however, that we have nothing that either indicates his paternity or places him and his supposed mother in the same place at the same time. While we have evidence of Julia Turner’s existence as well as evidence of her maternity of several children with the Gines surname, we have no record of her association with or marriage to any one named Gines.

Before we proceed, a word about the census records.  In a post here several months ago, we discusses several spelling variations for the name “Gines” (which in the family we’re following is pronounced with a “hard”  “G”).  Among those variations is “Guynes.”   We’ve also found people named Gines under “Gions,” “Giones,” and other spellings.  We know that these are mere variant spellings because the same persons sometimes end up with several of the spellings over time. [See here to figure out another way we know the difference between variant spellings and "true" variations in a name].

So, with the foregoing said, let’s look again at the last census record in which Julia appears with the Turner family.  It’s 1880.   The purpose of re-examining this record to is see whether there are likely candidates to be the father of Julia’s Gines child.

In 1880, the Turners, including Julia, were enumerated in Ward 4 of Tensas Parish, Louisiana.  Their household ( #76) appears on page 164 of the Tensas Parish census.  So let us look around for people named Gines who possibly and plausibly be the father of Egans Gines.

At the top of page 164, we find that Household #74 is occupied by Milford Guiones and wife Rebecca, along with their children, Ellen, Mary, Charles, and Dorsey. By comparing these names to other census records, we can reasonably surmise that this family is actually named “Gines” (for example, see Louisiana State Archives, death certificate entry for Milford Gines, died on 8 Apr 1930, aged 81 years).

milford-la-archives

1870-tensas-milford-et-al

Top: Entry for death of Milford Gines

Bottom: 1870 Census of Tensas Parish; note family # 701

(click images to enlarge)

But Milford’s family is of little use thus far; let’s put them aside for the moment, and lok further into the 1880 census.

At the bottom of page 163, in household #73, we find Elijah Guions, with wife Caroline and children Benjamin, Jane, Prisilla, Lucinda, and Elijah Jr.

Benjamin is 21 years old and Elijah, Jr. is 12.  It would not be an unreasonable hypothesis that he may have been involved with (assuming her age was correctly reported in 1870) the approximately 20 year old Julia Turner.  Recall that while this Guions family was in household #73, the Turners were in household #76.

Now comes that point in every genealogical problem where we pause a moment to lament the lack of an 1890 census. <pause> .  Thank you very much.

Recall that in the 1900 census, Julia Gines is listed as a widow.  And we don’t know who her husband was or who all of her children were.

We set out to find something about Egans Gines.  We knew only what his death certificate told us and an entry in the Shreveport city directory.  We found no marriage records for him or his parents. We found no specific evidence that he had any children.  We think he might be a sibling of  Tillman Gines, Zeke Gines, or Jeff Gines, the sons of Julia Turner Gines.

So are we any further along than when we started?  The goal of chasing Egans Gines as a collateral was to find a way around the brick wall that’s kept us from getting past Richard William Gines.  We’re not past that brick wall. Nonetheless, chasing down Egans has led us to numerous other collaterals who might prove more useful.  In addition to that, we’ve learned some things about Tensas Parish that also may be of future benefit.  Until we analyze all that information, we won’t know if this was a wild goose chase or not.

Coming: Some of the Plantations of Tensas Parish

Egans Gines (??-1948)

In which we beat the bushes for a collateral relative in hopes of finding our way past a brick wall!

One of my big brick walls has been getting past my great-grandfather Richard Gines. [Another challenge I have is getting my voice recognition software to recognize that surname!] To deal with this brick wall I’ve been looking for collateral relatives all around Grandpa Dick. In the course of doing that I’ve turned up some names that I can’t quite place.

Recently I found in the Louisiana State Archives a death certificate for one Egans Gines. I had not come across this name any place else before. So I went hunting for him in the census records, first to no avail. Then I did find in the Shreveport city directory for 1945-46 a person listed as “Eggens” Gines, most likely the same person. But that’s the only reference I found to Egan Gines anywhere.

The death certificate tells us that he was born on August 29, 1872, in St. Joseph, Louisiana.  St. Joseph is in Tensas Parish, a place where I haved found the surname Gines before. So I looked once again at the census records for Tensas Parish and once again, no Egans Gines. So let’s see what else we might glean from the death certificate. Well, he lived in Shreveport, Caddo Parish, for a while; but, again, the only reference in Caddo parish is that entry in the Shreveport city directory.

The death certificate lists Egans’ mother as Julia Turner. The next step then is to find either a Julia Turner or a Julia Gines in Tensas Parish.

Keep in mind that if she was married to a man named Gines in 1872, then we may have a very narrow window of time to find her in the census records as Julia Turner. That’s because most African-Americans were not listed by name in the census until 1870.

As it happens, Julia Turner appears on the 1870 census of Tensas Parish as a 10-year old. She’s with her parents, Jeff Turner, age 50, and Caroline Turner, age 36, and four siblings. I should say that these people are her “apparent family” for the reason that, as we all know, the 1870 census did not show relationships. They live in the prosaically named village of Waterproof, Louisiana.

This census record, if it is referring to our Julia Turner, makes apparent that either she is not the [two year old] mother of Egans Gines born in 1872, or he wasn’t born in 1872.

How does one resolve this dilemma?

I would stick, at the outset, with the working hypothesis that she is the mother of Egan, but that the death certificate is likely in error. If I develop further leads along this path, I can pursue them; if not, I’ll shift to a different hypothesis.

One factor in my thinking here is that although the census may be wrong about her age, it is more likely to be less wrong than the death certificate. Did you follow that?

The census record of Julia’s age was made by people who saw her, knew her, and overall had a better opportunity to judge her age. The death certificate record of Egans’ age was made decades after the fact by someone we don’t know anything about [more on that in this specific case later], who may not have known him well, or at all; whose memory may have faded or been clouded by the stress of the moment. So we continnue on the notion that Julia Turner is the mother of Egans Gines.

I spent some more time rooting around in the census records, and find that in 1880, Julia is still living with her parents and even more siblings. Her age is given as 16. There is no evidence that she has any baby, not to mention an 8 year old [which is how old Egans would be if he was really born in 1872].

A further search of census records turns up no more evidence of our Julia Turner.

So now we might seek evidence of a marriage of Julia to a man named Gines or direct evidence of her having given birth to a child named Egans Gines.

In several Louisiana marriage databases, we find a couple of possibilities. In January 1875, a Julia Ann Turner was married to Moses Jenkins in Tensas Parish. Our Julia Turner would have been either 11 or 15 years old, based on the census records. In May 1879, Julia Turner married Edward Palmer in Tensas Parish. Our Julia would have been about 15 or 19 at that time. This is one is a little more plausible than the first. But it doesn’t help because what of the Gines surnamed-baby? And what of the fact that the 1880 census shows her with her parents under her maiden name?

Neither of the last-asked questions above should be too difficult to explain and still find one of even both these marriages to have been our Julia. Noting for a moment that the 1870 census shows two Julia Turners, and that the “other” one plausibly could be marrying in 1879 at least, we’ll keep this information handy.

One way to test the idea that any of the Julia Turners is the our Julia Turner (in the absence of a marriage license or a birth certificate for the child Egans) would be to find her in the census with the child.

We make a discovery in the 1900 census. Living in Tensas Parish then is one Julia Gines with a birthdate of September 1860. [This takes a little work to verify, since the transcriptions at the usual places are horribly mangled!]

This Julia Gines is a widow with three sons, none being Egans. But we’re pretty sure this is the same Julia Turner we encountered earlier because the birthdate fits and the places of her parents’ nativities also fit. Somewhere between 1880 and 1900, she got married, had children, and lost her husband.

So where is Egans in 1900? Or for that matter, where is Egans anytime from his birth to his death?
In fact, where is Egans after his death? The death certificate says he was buried in Fairfield Cemetery in Shreveport. I’m told by a knowledgeable source that the cemetery no longer exists–there is an apartment complex on the site.

Coming soon: The Round-About Way Around Collaterals to your Brickwall–more on the Egans Gines case study.

Then: Some of the Plantations and Slave Owners of Tensas Parish, Louisiana

Graduation Daze

Milestone Graduations in the family

hvm-grad-1955 May 1955: Harold V. Manson receives his Bachelor of Journalism degree at Lincoln University, Jefferson City, Missouri.  Also in the picture are his wife, Lillian Gines Manson (left), who had graduated from Lincoln two years earlier; and his mother, Jessie Beatrice Bowie (1909-1973) (right, holding future genealogist).   Harold Manson was just the second person descended from Jane Manson (1823-??) to graduate from college; the first was his aunt Pansy Manson Warren (1909-1998).

hcm-afa

June 1976: The present author becomes the first descendant of Jane Manson and the first descendant of Richard Gines (1860-??) to graduate from a United States service academy, in this case, the United States Air Force Academy near Colorado Springs, Colorado.

ebowie-1977-1

June 1977: Vennis T. (“Terry”) Manson becomes the first descendant of Jane Manson or Richard Gines to graduate from a University of California campus; in this case, UC Santa Barbara.  Also in the photo are great-uncle Elias Bowie (1910-2005) (left), father Harold V. Manson, and brother David Q. Manson (center).

dq-qvhm-manson-1981

June 1981:  David Q. Manson talks with his grandfather, Quentin V.H. Manson (1913-1987) moments before his graduation as the top Army ROTC cadet at Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo.

Now show us some of your milestone graduation photos!

All photographs copyright MansonMedia. All rights reserved. Originals in possession of Craig Manson, Carmichael, California.

Blogging Catch-up

UPDATED 5/16/09 7:45 PM PDT (links added; spelling corrected; categories added)

Much going on here as the law school gets ready for graduation Saturday TODAY!  So we’ve  been a little slow on the blog.  Here are a few things we missed:

1. Another big thank you to the volunteers at Find – a- Grave!  More pictures have been found and taken.  More about that later.

2.  Cheryl Fleming Palmer bestowed us with the Friendly Blogger a ward last week.  Cheryl writes Heritage Happens — a great blog that I enjoy a lot .  So so I’m particularly pleased to accept the award from her.  I regret that it’s taken so long for us to recognize her publicly although I did post a comment on Cheryl’s blog.

friendlybloggeraward

Although it’s late I will pass the award forward to some friendly bloggers that I know as follows:

Thomas MacEntee, the genius behind a number of blogs, but especially Destination: Austin family and the Genea-bloggers blog.

Carol Yates Wilkerson of  iPentimento

Lisa at 100 years in America.

Kathryn Doyle at the California Genealogical Society & Library blog

Colleen at Orations of  OMcHodoy

Terry Snyder, the Desktop Genealogist Unplugged

Judith Richards Shubert who does Genealogy Traces

Jennifer of Rainy Day Genealogy Readings.

I know some of you have gotten it more than once but this is what I had in mind when I first got it and so I stayed with it.  Again we’ve been so busy with school and finals that I didn’t have time to get around to this earlier.

In any event, as summer approaches we’ve got a number of interesting things planned here so stay tuned.  For example, will talk more about the DNA adventure, as well as some progress we’ve made on some brick walls.  We’ve got some stories coming and some product reviews.

Smile for the Camera: Piper’s Debut

im000318

2 Year old Piper* Surveys Her Inheritance

(*Lady Piper Girl Dog Pudah [Puderhead] II Piper-Stop-That-Get-Down-Off-the Furniture-Dammit, Sub-Canine of the Realm, heiress to the Domain of Honey in Mansonshire)

This is the first photographer of Piper since the March 21, 2009, announcement that she will succeed 15 year old Honey (Duchess Honey D Dog Honey U Girl Dog Pudah [Puderhead] I You’re-a-Good-Dog, Canine of the Realm, Alpha of Honey in Mansonshire).

The Census Explained

The 1890 census was one of the most controversial up to that time. It therefore attracted a great deal of commentary in the press. The following article  confirms much of what you’ve probably thought about the census.  And many interesting contextual facts may  be gleaned from the story.   It originally appeared in the New York Tribune, but was reprinted in major cities around the country.  It is presented below as it appeared in the Knoxville Journal and Tribune on April 22, 1890.

CENSUS TAKING
_______________
Trials and Tribulations of the
Enumerators
______________________

A Rare Berth In Which to Study Human
Nature–Queer Questions, Queerer People,
and the Queerest of Answers

“If you want to have some fun studying human nature,” said a book-agent the other day, “get yourself enrolled as a census enumerator for a district where the people are indifferently educated. I tell you canvassing for orders is nothing to it, in the way of diversion. I know, for I was an enumerator myself in a thickly populated down town East side district of this city ten years ago when the last census was taken and though I only made about forty dollars for two weeks of the hardest work I ever performed in my life, yes, I have applied for the place again this year and hope to engage in another cross-questioning campaign with one eye wide open for fun. I’ll meet plenty of queer people, I warrant you, and as I am authorized by the law to enter every house and extract the desired information from any adult, under a penalty of a fine for refusal to aid me, you see I have things pretty much my own way in the end, though I often have to do a heap of talking before I get what I want, and in some instances, no doubt, will have to call the nearest policeman.”

Suppose the census enumerator begins on one of those five-story appartment houses,with four sets of rooms on each floor, each occupied by from four to nine rooms. He starts in the basement as follows:

” You’re the janitor, aren’t you?”

” Yes,” (resentfully as is the way of janitors who think you want them to show you an empty flat).

“How many families in the house?”

” What you want to know fer? (suspiciously). You can’t sell no books here.” (Glancing at your portfolio and blanks).

“I don’t want to sell books. I’ve come to take the census.”

” Oh, they’ve all got some excuse to get inside the house and some of ‘em ‘ll take any thin’ they can kin git ther hands on.”

“But I’m a Government official and I’ve come to take the census.”

” What’s that?”

“Well, if you don’t know what the census is, it’s time you found out. I’m going to count the people who live in this house, and if you interfere with me, I’ll call a policeman and have you fined. Look at  that–” and I show him my written authority signed by the Superintendent of the Census and the local supervisor. The seal on this generally fetches the janitor, and so I pass the watchdog and get inside the house. I rap on the door of one apartment and am confronted by a frowsy woman.

“Is the lady of the flat in, ma’am?”

“I’m her.”

“I’ve come to take the census.”

“Ain’t got any.”

Then follow extended explanations and finally we approach business.

“How old is your oldest child?”

“Well, she’s about that high,”   holding her hand about four feet from the floor.

“About twelve?”  I suggest knowing from experience that the exact year of the child’s birth has been crowded out of her tired mind by many subsequent sorrows and privations.

“I guess so.”

“And the next one?”  I continue.

“Oh!  It’s only a wee bit thing.”

“Yes, but can’t you remember when it was born?”

“Well, it was just after Thomas sent up.”

“How long was he in?”  I say, jumping at the clew.

“Five years.”

“And when did he get out?”

“Last Christmas.”

“Then the child’s almost six?”

“I guess so.”

“And how old is your husband?”

“I dunno.”

“Think now; did you ever hear him say?”

“Well, I heard him say once he was born in the year of the big wind in Ireland.”

More people in this generation were born during, or after, or just before, the “big wind in Ireland” than in any ten years before or since, I believe, but I persevere.

“Is he older than you?”

“Sure.”

“How much?”

“Not much.”

“How old are you?”

“It’s none of your business, young man; don’t be askin’ imperint questions.”

“But I must know, ma’am.  If I don’t ask you, I’ll be fined myself, and if you don’t answer you’ll be fined.”

“Well, I’m thirty-nine.”

It’s truly wonderful how many women there are who are either nineteen, or twenty-nine, or thirty-nine, or forty-nine.  Do they hate to acknowledge that they  have at last left the decade in which they have carried for ten or fifteen years or is there an amazing but hitherto unnoticed decrease in the birth of girl babies one year out of every ten?  Still I hold my peace and put down this woman as thirty-nine, though she is forty-five if she’s a day,  and I put down her man, who is not much older, as forty-two. This is about as near as you can come with these people, and the woman has done as well as the average in the way of being willing to tell the little she really knows.

But then there is another class of questions that generally causes more trouble than the ages, because people are generally quite unwilling to tell the truth with respect to them.  These are the questions about the “dependent, defective and delinquent” classes, as the last census sheets tabulated them.  It takes some gall to ask a big fiery woman, whom you have been pestering for a quarter of an hour about her age, if any of her family are idiots, or deformed, or criminals, and if so how many, and what are their special forms of disease or rascality. Only a hardened book agent, life-insurance canvasser or lightning-rod peddler can do it every time without quailing or minding the shower of indignant abuse that comes thickest and fastest from a mother who really has a weak-minded son, or a hump-backed daughter, or a jailbird husband. I fancy that we get correct answers in the affirmative to these questions about once in fifty or so.

But a great deal depends on how you put the question.  Only a green horn would say: “Any of you crazy?” Your expert book agent says, “All their minds correct?  Speech all right?  Can everybody see?  Is the hearing perfect with all of you?”  I tell you tact is what an enumerator chiefly needs if  he is going to get through his work quick enough to make any money out of it.  It’s no soft snap.  The temptation to sit down and fill in the blanks, to the best of your own judgment, and sooner, than spend half an hour with an abusive and ignorant family, is almost irresistible at times, in a heavy penalty attaches to such work, and justly, too.

At the last census many men applied for the place of enumerator, thinking it a picnic, and when they received their books and instructions and began to grasp the size of the job, they resigned in large numbers.  This year, to guard against any such monkey business, an enumerator who accepts his appointment and then backs out without giving a
satisfactory reason to the superintendent, may be fined and imprisoned.

The city is so divided that each enumerator is supposed to have about two thousand individuals to inquire about.  But he often finds that his district is much more thickly populated than he supposed.  I remember last time I got into a room in a wretched house where four families dwell together the room was partitioned off into four rectangles, but not in the usual way with wooden walls, but by chalk lines on the floor.

“How do you all manage to live in such crowded quarters?”  I asked, jogged out of my routine questions by their unusually sardine-like arrangement.

“Oh, we’d get on well enough,” growled one man, “if them Joneses wouldn’t persist in keeping boarders.”