Archive for Oklahoma

African-Native American Research: A Chat with Author Nita Ighner

A few years ago, I came across a blog entitled “Diggin’ Up Bones.” It was extremely well done, recording the research odyssey of its author, Nita Ighner. Her journey took her to the Carolinas where she learned some very interesting things about her family history. She did archival research as well oral history–all quite impressive. Ighner is a college professor teaching American Sign Language at a college in Southern California. She is the author of an ASL study guide. She’s also an accomplished artist in several media and holds a patent on a doll that she designed.

More recently, Nita has started off on another path in her family history – exploring her Native American roots. On this journey she has provided us once again the benefit of her learning two new books published this summer.

GeneaBlogie recently had the honor and privilege ask Nita some questions about her research and her books.

GeneaBlogie: Tell us a little bit about how your own search for your ancestors got started. What was the one thing, if there was one thing, that compelled you to look for them?

Nita Ighner: I didn’t wonder too much about my mother’s side of the family because she always told us family stories and I knew my grandparents and all of my mother’s siblings. However, my father was an only child who was raised by his grandparents and we knew only knew his father. He later introduced us (I have two brothers and two sisters) to his mother, who he never lived with. My father’s side of the family was a mystery to us for years. That’s the reason I started my search 20 years ago.

Nita IghnerAuthor Nita Ighner

G: You had a terrific blog called Diggin’ Up Bones, which chronicled your search for ancestors on your father’s side of the family. It revealed some interesting things. Can you tell us about some of the most interesting parts about searching for ancestors on your father‘s side?

Nita: Thank you! On the 1880 Census for Newberry, South Carolina I found the names John and Nancey Ighner. I wasn’t sure how or even if they were apart of my family, but I was hoping that they were since we knew nothing beyond my small family. On that census record were listed three young mulatto granddaughters living with John and Nancey named Carrie, Clara, and Sophina. There was no indication as to who their parents were. For some reason, those girls became my obsession. I had to find out who they were and what had happened with them. Well, years later when I did make contact with family members in Newberry, S.C., I was invited to my first family reunion. My two sisters and I attended the reunion in Chattanooga, Tennessee. Just the sight of the family name – Eigner – on the marquee made me extremely proud and extremely emotional. After our first family meeting I was approached by a cousin who handed me a video tape. She told me that her 97 year old mother – Erleen Eigner Paschal – had heard that I was going to be attending the reunion and wanted me to watch the tape. Erleen also sent me a message inviting me to visit her in North Carolina as soon as possible because she didn’t know how long she would be with us. A few days after having returned home from the reunion I decided to watch the tape. On that tape Erleen narrated the family’s story. I could not believe my ears. It turned out that my 97 year old cousin was the daughter of Clara, one of the three granddaughters on the 1880 Census! Needless to say, I flew to visit her immediately. What a darling woman she was. It is because of her that I know so much about my family today. She was able to give me many names and tell me many remarkable family stories. I found out that the reason the three girls’ mother was not listed on the census record was because she had died of Consumption. Their father was not listed because he was white. Erleen remembered her grandfather very clearly. My cousin’s father – Asa Eigner – was my great uncle. He was the brother of my great-grandfather John Ighner Jr., and John Jr., was the grandfather who raised my father. I’ll never forget what Erleen told me after my visit. She said, “I loved you from the first time I saw you.” I truly felt the same of her. Erleen died at the age of 107. In addition to all of that wonderfulness, I found and ordered copies of my ancestors’ slave owner’s Will. In there I found the names of my g-g-g-grandparents John Eigner l and his mother Adeline.

G: You followed Diggin’ Up Bones with another terrific blog called Erma’s Roots or On the Other Side. As the name suggested, it was about the search for ancestors on your mother side of the family. What were some most interesting parts about searching for your mother’s ancestors?

Nita: Thank you again! I was amazed to find my great-grandfather Wesley Galloway and his brother Henry on the 1870 Grant, Arkansas Census. I also found my great-grandparents’ – Wesley and Josephine Galloway – wedding certificate application.

G: One of the things that I found interesting was that you seem to know a little more about your father’s African ancestry than his Native American ancestry, but on your mother’s side you know more about her Native American ancestry than you do her African ancestry. Can you tell us about about that?

Nita: There is a difference in my family search methods because even though I know that my g-g-grandmother Nancy Horsey Suber Eigner was half Native American and was brought to Newberry, SC on horseback by her father when she was age 5 then sold (tragic), no one knows which tribe she belonged. The only thing we have to hang onto is that Nancy remembered her father’s name, which was Horsey and that he would call out to his horse the word(s) “Gullapalucha”. Of course that’s phonetically spelled. I have been conducting my own study to try and find the tribe my father’s family is from by cross-referencing the word(s) with Native American vocabulary that might appear similar in its spelling. I’m still searching. Erleen was also able to tell me that my g-g-grandmother Harriet Darby Eigner was Ibo and Gullah.

As for my mother’s side of the family, it’s always been known that my grandfather’s line is part Choctaw. I’ve only gone up to 1870’s through my grandmother’s line. There’s still much to do.

G: Now, in the course of your initial research into your family’s history, you actually went to South Carolina and met people on the ground, so to speak. Did you meet any descendants of former slave owners, and if so, how did they treat you?

Nita: Yes. I did visit South Carolina many times for my research and to visit my newly found family. It has been FANTASTIC! They have been amazingly kind. However, I haven’t met any of the slave owner’s descendents in South Carolina. For several years, however, I did – at one time – keep up regular communications with one of the slave owner’s descendents by phone. She lives in Mississippi. She was very sweet and invited me to stay with her family for a vacation. I never did. She also sent me a photo of her ancestors.

G: I want to turn now to your two books which recently have been published. They’re available through Amazon.com and Barnes & Noble’s BN.com. We’ll talk more about the availability of your books in just a minute. The two books are first, “Choctaw Minor Freedman Enhanced,” which contains Choctaw tribal enrollment figures and a few other things we’ll talk about in a minute as well. And the second book is “The 1900 African-American census in the Seminole and Muscogee nations.” Let’s take the first book, the Choctaw enrollment numbers. There may be some who are not familiar as to what your title refers. What is meant by “Freedman” in this context?

Nita: The term Freedman – in reference to my books – refers to those of African heritage who were slaves owned by Native Americans such as the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Creek and Seminole Nations.

G: And what is meant by “Minor” Freedman?

Nita: “Minor Freedman” was the term given to a child or children born to those freed slaves. They were born between the years of 1899 and 1906.

G: The title of the second book also alludes to “slaveowners.” Is it true that the Choctaw owned slaves?

Nita: A quick answer for your question is ‘Yes indeed! Choctaw Indians owned slaves.’ I must say that the Choctaws weren’t the only indigenous people to own slaves. In fact, all five tribes of the Civilized Indian Nations owned slaves. And as if that weren’t enough, many slaves marched the Trail of Tears along side their owners. Your question is very important. For years, many African-American families – including mine – have passed down little snippets of stories or the memory of physical features that allude to the possibility of sharing Indian blood. Sometimes those stories take us only so far then leave us wondering as did the ancient world maps that hinted at monsters beyond a certain point without one bit of proof. Due to the assimilation of European cultural behaviors, many Indian tribes proudly owned slaves. It doesn’t matter if only 3% or 8% of them owned slaves, it didn’t make a slaves life any better. And it doesn’t matter how they purportedly treated their slaves well, a slave owner is a slave owner. It’s important for us to know that it was the institution of slavery that most likely made it possible for us to claim Indian heritage.

There are a few people out there working hard to keep us informed about this part of our history. Angela Y. Walton-Raji has done an astounding job for years on the subject. She manages the African-Native American Genealogy Forum on Afrigeneas web site as well as taking on many other duties. The information is there for all who need it. We just have to look for it.

G: In the second book, you present the 1900 African-American census in the Seminole and Muscogee nations. Why is this particular census is important?

Nita: I chose the 1900 Seminole and Muscogee for my second book for two reasons. One, I’m simply chipping away at the massive amount of information that’s out there and trying to make it more convenient for those who are in need of it. Two, I find that family names from the 1900 Census seem to be easily remembered by our older family members than the names prior to that time.

G: Is there some present significance or relevance to the Seminole and Muscogee nations’ relationship with African-Americans?

Nita: From what I’ve read, the Seminole and Muscogee Nations were more culturally interactive with slaves to the point that some became leaders and scouts.

G: On your website which is www.soreheadbear.com, you seem to draw some parallels between indigenous North American tribes and African tribes. What do you think those parallels are and how have they informed the modern cultures of Native Americans and African Americans?

Nita: The earth exudes soul. I’ve found with indigenous groups around the world and particularly those of the Americas and of Africa that the reception of that soul speaks out in very similar ways. How many times have we said to ourselves and maybe to others, “Those guys are just like us!” when we recognize a sameness in one another indigenous groups? Whether people like it, believe it, or can’t even think about it, there is something of ourselves that we can readily see in others.

G: There seems to be a rift of sorts between some of the Native American tribes and their African ancestored members. What do you know about that and how do you feel about?

Nita: Simply said, assimilation is a bitch. It was all orchestrated and, boy, did it play out the way in which it was intended to. Andrew Jackson purposed a dilution of Native American blood by strongly suggesting that as many Europeans as possible marry into the Indian tribes. Why? For one thing, those European marriages assured the future ownership of American land. No treaties would need to be drawn for what would already be possessed by the right people. Also, by discouraging the mixture of Africans and Indians, the reservations would not become a safe haven for those who were brought here strictly for the purpose of carrying out the duties of servitude. And so, the idea was pretty much bought.

G: You are an artist by nature and profession. How have your artistic sensibilities influenced your search for ancestors?

Nita: That’s an exciting question. Beyond merely knowing my background, my art seems to bring forth the rhythm of my heritance without any conflicts. I can see that there is no fight in me as to who I am. There is only a truthful harmony that pours forth from my ancestors. If I want to know them, all I have to do is pay attention to what comes out of me. That is how they speak to me.

G: Have you met any Native American cousins over the years since you began your research? Tell us about that.

Nita: No I haven’t met any Native American cousins. That would be interesting. However, I have met several people of the Choctaw Nation that have asked me if I was part Choctaw. Confirmation does have a way of feeding the soul.

G: If you haven’t met any Native American cousins, do you expect to and what will you say or do when you do meet them?

Nita: That would be exciting. I think I want to be surprised by it.

G: I want to talk for a minute about the books – the logistics of the books. They’re published by your own imprint, sorehead bear press, only in e-book format. So they’re available for Barnes & Noble’s NOOK and Amazon.com’s Kindle. Did you have any trepidation about publishing only in the e-book format?

Nita: My initial intent was to publish them in hardbound. It wasn’t until I had already put my information in book form that I realized how convenient it would be to go eBook with them. I have a NookColor and LOVE being able to read books that would otherwise be much too heavy to carry around. I can do my research wherever I go. And needless to say, I can regulate the price and make my work much more accessible to the readers. It’s a great tool. I’m able to search specific names, highlight, bookmark, etc. EBooks are absolutely wonderful!

G: I have always admired your work ethic. What kind of discipline did it take to sit down and create these books and how long did you think about them before you got down to the business of researching and writing?

Nita: I believe my ability to do this kind of detailed work is just a part of my quirky personality. I do the same with very detailed art. I get an idea and I immediately go for it. I usually come right in from work and get on the computer. Sometimes it can be everyday for a month or several months. I tear away at my purpose until it’s done. And I have to admit that sometimes in the midst of it I say to myself, “WHAT WAS I THINKING?”

G: What kind of reception have you gotten in the African-American and Native American communities about your project?

Nita: To be truthful, only a couple of people have encouraged me with their admiration for my work. I don’t let a lack of support influence my desire to compile and publish as much information as I can. I’m meeting my own goals and that’s what keeps me going.

G: It’s quite apparent from your work that family means a lot to you; for example, the website is dedicated to your grandfather, the Bishop Joseph Galloway. And you’ve made mention in several places of your brother, the renowned composer Benard Ighner. Have you gotten lots of support from your family on this project?

Nita: My Uncle Alfred who is the last of nine siblings in my mother’s family is very supportive and excited about my projects. My own siblings are extremely supportive and though they might get lost in my genealogical ramblings, they listen anyway. We’ve all been blessed with talent of some sort and we adore one another’s work. My mother – who passed away 9 years ago – raised us to be supportive. My oldest sister Jo writes and paints. Benard, my oldest brother continues to leave the imprint of his musical genius on the world. My sister Sandy was the first African-American woman to sing with Sergio Mendes and has since sang all over the world. And my youngest brother Keith is a phenomenal bassist and composer whose work was recorded by Freddie Hubbard when he was just 17. So, when you look at it, this is probably just me doing my thing. And they are supportive even still. My mother had a saying when we shared our projects with her. She’d say, “I’m so far in your corner that you can’t even get in there.” And that’s how my siblings and I are to one another.

G: When can we expect more publications from Nita Ighner?

Nita: I’m working on three things right now. Two of them are genealogical in nature, concerning the Chickasaw Nation and the slaves in South Carolina. And I’ve just started a book of fictional short stories that will also be published on eBooks. So, you’ll be seeing something else from me soon.

Nita: Thank you so much for this wonderful opportunity to talk about my work. For someone whose work I have admired for such a long time, it is quite a compliment to be interviewed by you. Thank you again.

G: Thank you! It was a privilege.

Read Nita’s books

1900 African-American Census in the Seminole and Muscogee Nations

Amazon.com

Barnes & Noble

 

 

 

Choctwa minor FreedmenChoctaw Minor Freedmen Enhanced

Amazon.com

Barnes & Noble

 

 

 

Learn more about the black members of tribes in America:

Black Indian & Intertribal Native American Association

Cherokee by Blood

Freedmen of the Five Civilized Tribes

Afrigeneas African-Native American Genealogy Forum

 

Halloween Census Whacking

With the crisis of my father’s recent illness and the minor drama of my own, I feel like I’ve been way out of touch the last two weeks.  It’s time get back into the flow of things.   I thought  little census whacking for Halloween would ease my way back into writing.  So I went hunting for Vampires, Zombies, Ghosts, Ghouls, Goblins, Witches and Pumpkins.

Vampires

According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the incidence of Vampires is extremely low in the United States.  In 1880,  four Vampires: Otto; Jean; Julianne; and Mary, all in their twenties, were living in Cheyenne,  Wyoming.  They claimed to be actors. In 1870,  there was just one Vampire in the United States, 26 year-old machinist George Vampire.  Of course he lived in New York City.   What happened to these five Vampires  in the 20th century?  Were they forced to leave or did they on their own just pull out up stakes and leave?

According to the World Names Profiler (WNP), Germany and the United States have the greatest incidence of Vampires in the world.  Germany’s statistic is 0.04 per million, while in the U.S., the figure is 0.01 Vampires per million people.  Regionally, the American Vampires are located in Oklahoma, according to the WNP.  The Sooner state has a Vampire index of 1.04 per million.  With a 2008 estimated population of 3,640,000 or so,  there would be about four Vampires in Oklahoma.   I found in public records three listings in Lawton, Oklahoma, for Madonna Vampire.  Unfortunately for her, there are at least thirty people named Buffy in Oklahoma presently.

Zombies

Nearly all the Zombies in the census records turned out to be mis-transcriptions of other names.  The WNP reports no Zombies in the United States.  Public records reviews show about 14 Zombies in various places around the country.

Ghosts

Kraft Ghost of Fayette County, Pennsylvania, and Leonard Ghost of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, both listed on the 1790 federal census appear to be the first two Ghosts in America.  But in the 1900 census, the number of Ghosts expands exponentially.  Most of these “new” Ghosts are Native Americans in the upper Midwest.  The WNP indicates a Ghost index of 18.29 per million in South Dakota and 3.37 per million in Nebraska.  South Dakota’s estimated 2008 population was 804,000, which would yield about 15 Ghosts. Public records reveal about 17 Ghosts in South Dakota (when obvious duplicates are eliminated).

Nebraska’s estimated population is about 1.8 million, suggesting something a bit more than six Ghosts.  I was able to find only one Ghost in Nebraska in public records. The rest seem to have vanished.

And how about Pennsylvania where it seems to have begun for Ghosts in America?   WNP’s Pennsylvania Ghost index is 2.58 per million.   That would mean about 32 Ghosts presently among Pennsylvania’s estimated 12.45 million folks.  I was able to identify 25 Ghosts in Pennsylvania public records after eliminating duplicates and two entries which appeared to refer to religious organizations.

Ghouls

Apparently, the first Ghoul in America was 66 year-old Christian Ghoul of Maryland, a German immigrant.  He appears on the 1870 census.  Few other Ghouls seem to have been counted until the 1900 census, where like the Ghosts, the Ghouls grew rapidly in number.  And like the Ghosts, most of the “new” Ghouls were Indians, living primarily in Tehama County, California.

When it comes to Ghouls, the United States doesn’t even register in the WNP top ten. (Number one is France, with a Ghoul incidence of 4.59 per million; Switzerland is a distant second at 1.92 per million, supporting evidence that the Gauls may be the most Ghoulish people on Earth). (Hey, I just report the facts!)

Within in the U.S., however, Ghouls seem to be concentrated around Las Vegas and Chicago, at least according to the WNP.  Clark County, Nevada, which includes Las Vegas, and Will County, Illinois, adjacent to Chicago, were the only two counties in which the WNP found any Ghouls at all. Curiously, public records show no Ghouls in Nevada and six in the Chicago area.  Overall, public records indicate something more than 100 Ghouls in America presently, with perhaps as many as 10% of those in California.   This is the biggest disparity I’ve ever seen between WNP data and public records. [The WNP's FAQs state: "All our names and location data are derived from publicly available telephone directories or national electoral registers, sourced for the period 2000-2005."]

Goblins

A man named Goblin was first in recorded in New York City in the 1850 census.  In 1860 there was still just one Goblin on the census and that was 14-year-old Lucinda Goblin who lived with the Davenport household in Columbia, Missouri.  But just 10 years later, the 1870 census showed that three fourths of the (four) Goblins in the USA lived in North Carolina.  By 1900 however, the number of Goblins in America had increased nearly eight-fold to a total of 33, to be found in every region of the country.

Globally, the number of Goblins in the U.S. doesn’t make the slightest statistical ripple, using WNP data.  Number one is France, again, with  0.2 Goblins per million.  The United Kingdom is far, far, behind with 0.02 per million.

Witches

We all know the history of Witch hunts in America. Surprisingly enough however only one Witch appears on the 1790 census and that would be Peter Witch of Lancaster County, Pennsylvania (just what is it with Pennsylvania and Lancaster in particular?).  There was also a Witch in Rutledge County, Alabama, in 1790.  By 1900, Witches were routinely enumerated in the census all over the country.  Sadly, two of them were little boys: Jacob Witch, 10 years old, and his brother, Henry Witch five years old, who were apparently in an orphanage in Las Galinas, Marin County, California.

Turns out that there are far more Witches in the U.K. and Canada than in the USA (the only countries reporting any Witches at all).  The British Witch population (0.5 per million) is concentrated in Newport (Casnewydd), Wales, and the southwest jurisdictions of North Somerset, Bath and Northeast Somerset, as well as the City of Bristol.  There are also a few Witches in Surrey.

According to WNP, Manitoba’s  Witch frequency of 2.93 per million accounts for the whole of Canada’s 0.23 per million Witch index. Manitoba has an estimated population of 1.2 million; all of Canada consists of 31.6 million people. Mathematically, that does not work out.  Unfortunately the WNP provincial map of Manitoba gives no further details.

The U.S. Witch frequency is a comparatively minuscule 0.04 per million.  WNP finds Witches concentrated in Dickinson County, Kansas, and Howard County, Maryland.  A public records search reveals about twelve Witches in  the USA (eliminating commercial enterprises like plumbing and construction ["Ditch Witch"] and fast food restaurants [Fish Witch"]).  None of the Witches were found in Kansas and of the two in Maryland, neither was in Howard County.

Pumpkins

John Pumpkin appears as the only one of his surname on the 1820 census.  He lived in Fayette Count, Kentucky.  Virtually no other Pumpkins are found in the census until 1880.  In that year, Pumpkins were concentrated in two areas of the country: Fresno County, California, and Greene County, Georgia.  The latter jurisdiction included a young lady, 15 years old, named  Etta Pumpkin.  Following a pattern that we’ve seen before, the 1900 census showed a huge increase in the number of Pumpkins in America. Again this had to do with the number of Native Americans enumerated on the census in that year.  The Indian Pumpkins were primarily on reservations in the upper Midwest.  By 1910, however, they were concentrated in Madera County, California, and Cherokee County, Oklahoma.  The Oklahoma Pumpkins included one Mary Pumpkin Gritts.

The WNP data shows the expected distribution of Pumpkins in the USA based on historical data.  South Dakota, Montana, and Oklahoma are leading Pumpkin states, based presumably on the frequency of the name among Indians.

Other “Important” News

While I was whacking away on Halloween themes, I started wondering about some other things. Not only did I find unexpected discrepancies with the usually reliable World Names Profiler, but I also now have reason to question the competence of the Census Bureau, whose data report not a single Fool, Clown, or Jackass has ever been enumerated in Washington, D.C.

The Rest of Paul Harvey’s Story–Part 1

Even as he represented a kind of normalcy and stability, broadcasting legend Paul Harvey’s personal story was unusual.  Murder, the Ku Klux Klan, perhaps a secret marriage, a grand jury probing the possible theft of  atomic secrets–all of these things are part of the rest of Paul Harvey’s story.

Paul Harvey Aurandt was born on September 4, 1918, in Tulsa, Oklahoma.  His father was Harry Harrison Aurandt, a Tulsa police officer, and his mother was Anna Dagmar Christensen, a Danish immigrant. The Aurandt family traces its lineage back to Johannes Aurandt, born in Hohenstein in about 1590. He died in about 1637.  Paul Harvey’s direct ancestor also named  Johannes Aurandt (1725-1808) came to America in the 18th century and settled Pennsylvania. Harry Harrison Aurandt, Paul’s father, was born in Martinsburg, Pennsylvania in 1873.  Harry’s father, William Aurandt, died when Harry was less than two years old.  Harry eventually moved west and met Anna Dagmar Christensen, who had immigrated to America from Denmark.   They were married in Princeton, Mercer County, Missouri, which is on the Iowa border.  At some point, they moved to Witchita, Kansas, and from there to Tulsa.  Their daughter, Frances, was born in 1909.

In Tulsa, Harry was a police officer and apparently was fairly saavy at the job.  He became secretary to the police commissioner.  His wife Dagmar was something of a social maven, frequently appearing “Here, There, and Everywhere in Social Tulsa,” (which was the name of a society column in the Tulsa World).

On December 18, 1921, when his son Paul was three years old, Harry Aurandt was off duty with a friend, Chief Detective Ike Wilkinson.  They went rabbit-hunting.  As they drove,

they observed a car standing facing south; after proceeding a short distance past this other car the car in rear followed and passed the car occupied by Wilkinson and Aurandt, and as they passed Wilkinson and Aurandt observed three revolvers protruding from the curtains inclosing the car and heard a command, accompanied by oaths, to stop their car. In response to this command Wilkinson and Aurandt guided their car to the side of the paving and stopped; the car from which the command to stop had been given drove past them and stopped immediately in front of the car occupied by Wilkinson and Aurandt, at a place about 17 to 20 feet from where their car stood. The lights of Aurandt’s car were on, so that the space around the car ahead was illuminated.

[Two men emerged from the car] both with revolvers in their hands [and began shooting].. . . Wilkinson, while preparing to alight, was severely wounded in the thigh and leg, which  caused him to sink back into the car seat. During the drive preceding the shooting Wilkinson had a small bore shotgun, looking for rabbits to shoot as they drove along; during the affray he attempted to shoot at [one of the bandits] with this shotgun, but the gun snapped and the shell failed to explode, and while he was in the act of trying to use the second barrel a shot from [the assailant's] revolver knocked the gun out of Wilkinson’s hands.

Cook v. State, 226 P. 595, 27 Okl.Cr. 215, 217-18 (1924).

Aurandt was wounded in the lungs and liver.  Despite being so gravely wounded, Harry Aurandt drove himself and Wilkinson away from the scene to a residence about a mile and a half distant.  Aurandt and Wilkinson were taken to the hospital as Tulsa city police and the Tulsa County sheriff formed posses to track the assailants.

Harry Aurandt died in the hospital two days after the incident.

The aftermath of the shooting turned into one of the most bizarre series of events in Oklahoma history.  Four men were identified as suspects:  Alvis Fears, Tom W. Cook, Bill Dalton, and Frank Shelton.  Fears and Cook were “well-known  to the authorities.”   It is not clear whether “Shelton” and “Dalton” aliases or not.

Within hours, three of them, Fears, Cook, and “Dalton” were taken into custody. As word spread that the suspects had been apprehended, a crowd began to congregate around the Tulsa courthouse.  It was soon evident that the crowd, estimated at 1,500 or more, intended to lynch the suspects.

Tulsa County Sheriff W.M. “Bill” McCullough told the mob that the suspects had been removed to a place of safety.  The Tulsa World reported: “It was then proposed that a committee go through the jail to make sure.”

The committee consisted of a Presbyterian minister, a Methodist minister, and three other men. The Presbyterian minister, the Rev. C.W. Kerr, had been the Aurandts’ pastor.

The Sheriff let the committee into the courthouse and after a thorough search, Rev. Kerr reported that there was no sign of the inmates.  He then gave an impassioned speech in which he urged the crowd not to “blacken the reputation of Tulsa,” and that “the law must be allowed to take its course.”  Kerr was persuasive and the crowd stood down and dispersed.

Sheriff McCullough had personally escorted the prisoners to Macalester, Oklahoma, earlier in the day when he had heard rumors of the intended lynching.

The bizarre events had only just begun.

The Tulsa World, in a strangely written story,  reported on  Harry Aurandt’s funeral:

The casket had just been lowered, the last words of the chaplain had just sounded, when swiftly, before the two or three hundred men and women gathered around the tent erected over the grave had time to make a movement, the white procession crossed the gravel road and passed single file through the aisle between the Knights Templar and the members of the police force.  No one had seen them come nor knew they were there.  On each uniform was the black and red insignia of the  KKK.

Entering the tent open at one side, they circled the grave.  The leader laid  the flaming cross that he carried upon the casket, each of the 11 dropped a rose upon it.  They made crimson splotches on the massed pink and white flowers that heaped the coffin.  Ministers, Masons, Knights Templar, uniformed policemen, and civilians stood in dazed silence as the Ku Klux Klan cross the road again and were gone.  Without a word the crowd slowly broke up and by the time people had reached their cars there was not a trace of any of the 12 white sheeted figures.

The Klansmen advanced toward the scene of burial in single file.  Their eyes were glued ahead with soldierly steadfastness.  A high wind was blowing and occasionally a strong blast would threaten to blow the flap like masks out of position and expose the face of the wearer.  But on all such occasions, the robed figures reached up and held the masks in place.  Although they had marched almost halfway across the cemetery, participants in the burial ceremonies were so engrossed they did not notice the approach until the Klansmen were only a few feet away.  The twelve figures stopped and remained stationary until  the Masonic rites were completed.

When those in charge of the services saw them nearby, they quickly stepped back and allowed sufficient room for the Klansmen to past between their lines.  Not a word was spoken as the figures performed their impressive and mysterious ceremonies.

No one in Tulsa has ever witnessed such a ceremony before, nor had they heard of it being performed in any other city.  Whether it is part of the Ku Klux Klan’s  established rites and ceremonies or if it was inspired locally is a matter of conjecture.

” Was he a member?”  “Does the blood red Rose have significance that could be taken to mean that the Klansmen intend to cherish the memory and avenge the untimely death of a brother?”

These were some of the  questions  that pass through the group of spectators when they had recovered from their surprise and the Klansmen had disappeared.

Tulsa World, December 22, 1921, p. 1

[NOTE:  There is no evidence that Harry Aurandt was a member of the KKK. In a  book published nine years ago, author Ron Owens offers an observation about the Klan's ceremony at Aurandt's funeral:

This was a fairly standard practice of the times and was not interpreted as indicative that the officer had been a member of the KKK.  The organization used these occasions to make a public appearance, probably intended a mute statement of their power and numbers, while symbolically paying their respects and announcing their dissatisfaction with the ultimate act of lawlessness, the murder of a law enforcement officer.  This interpretation was reinforced when the county sheriff and other law enforcement officers began receiving anonymous letters from the "Invisible Empire" demanding that they decrease they lawlessness or risk vigilante justice.

Owens, R., Oklahoma Heroes: The Oklahoma Peace Officers Memorial (Turner Publishing Co., 2000), page 42.

The reader may decide whether the Klan had standing to be dissatisfied with any act of lawlessness.  Other sources have documented KKK appearances at law enforcement funerals in the 1920's.  See for example the description of a Miami officer's funeral in 1925, where "special seating arrangements were made" for the Klan and "at either end of the casket stood a Knight of the Ku Klux Klan, keeping silent vigil over the form of his departed brother."  Wilbanks, W.,  Forgotten Heroes: Police Officers Killed in Dade County, 1895-1995 (Turner Publishing Co. 1997), page 36.  See also photograph of Klan parade at funeral for a slain Madison, Wisconsin, officer in 1902 at Wisconsin Historical Images.]

A few days after Harry Aurandt’s death, an insurance company  ran the following quarter-page ad in the Tulsa World:

atlas-life-ins-ad1

(click for larger image)

With several of the suspects in jail and the venue having been changed to Pawnee County, the trial commenced on April 10, 1922.  Although the prosecution called a number of expert and percipient witnesses, the testimony of Det. Wilkerson was key to the case.

The jury, after deliberating for fifty hours, convicted the defendants, and then sentenced them to life in prison.  But there was more fallout to come.

At the time of Harry Aurandt’s murder, John Calloway Walton was the mayor of Tulsa.  In 1922, this Hoosier-turned-Sooner rode a coalition of Socialists, farmers, and labor activists into the Governor’s office.  As Governor, he vowed to continue his fight against the Ku Klux Klan, which he had begun while mayor of Tulsa.

Walton carried on his war against the Klan with zeal.  He declared martial law in Okmulgee and Tulsa Counties and convened a military court in Tulsa to investigate the Klan.  He suspended the writ of habeas corpus in several counties in direct contravention of the Oklahoma Constitution.

Meanwhile, however, Walton had taken the Klan’s secret oath and had appointed some Klansmen to state jobs, believing he could win their support and cooperation.

Walton opposed the death penalty and was extremely liberal with paroles and pardons.  Following the conviction of the murderers of Paul Harvey’s father, Harry Aurandt, Walton granted a furlough pending appeal to Alvis Fears, one of the murderers.  Fears did not return to prison when scheduled  but instead remained a fugitive for some time thereafter, committing other crimes.

Fears was still at large in 1923, when Oklahoma’s  Court of Criminal Appeals was to hear his appeal in the Aurandt murder together with that of co-defendant Tom W. Cook.  The court dismissed Fears’ appeal because of his fugitive status.  As to Cook, the court held that much of the evidence relating to his identification was inadmissible hearsay.  His conviction was reversed and the case remanded for possible retrial.

In January, 1924, Fears was taken into custody near Tulsa by a force of officers from Oklahoma, Kansas, and Missouri.  He and some of the others were charged with robbing a bank in Ashbury, Missouri.  One of the others arrested at that time with Fears was Guy McKenzie.  McKenzie had been convicted in 1914 of murdering prominent Tulsa lawyer and school board member Charley Reuter.  Governor Walton had pardoned McKenzie in 1923.

Meanwhile, the Oklahoma Legislature had lost its patience  with the Governor’s dupliciousness and brought impeachment proceedings against Walton.  The Governor sought the intervention of the federal courts, but the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that federal courts lacked jurisdiction to hear the matter.

The Oklahoma Senate removed Walton from office in November 1923 for, among other things, “illegal collection of campaign funds, padding the public payroll, suspension of habeas corpus, excessive use of the pardon power, and general incompetence.”

I was unable to discover what ultimately became of the murderers.

Coming Next:  Did Paul Harvey have a secret marriage?  Why was he arrested by federal agents in 1950? The Rest of Paul Harvey’s Story Concludes

Obituary: Patricia Ellen Morrison


Patricia Ellen Morrison (nee Martin), born June 19, 1962, passed away Sunday, October 14, 2007. She was a member of the Kaw and Osage Nations.

Patty was a graduate of Baylor University and Baylor Law School. She was a member of Kappa Delta sorority. She practiced law with The Williams Companies Legal Department from 1990 to 2002. She was appointed by President Bush to the office of Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of the U.S. Department of the Interior in 2002, where she served until 2004. She is survived by: her husband, Kevin Morrison; son, Ilya both of Collinsville, Oklahoma; mother, Mary Ellen (Cross) Martin of Cushing, Oklahoma; sister, Susann Box of Cushing; and brother, John Martin, of Tulsa, Oklahoma.

Patty was an outstanding lawyer; an excellent friend and colleague. Her passing comes as quite a shock. Few words can describe the deep sympathy I feel for her husband Kevin and their son, Ilya.